Monday, March 19, 2012

The Business of Politics

Once upon a time, in a former life, I worked for a Fortune 500 company. They trained me in Project Management and sent me through Six Sigma certification, and I eventually became a member of the Global Business Process Team (as the most junior member).

I think I can say, with some confidence, that no business would make policy the way Congress does. I'm not talking about the kinds of decisions they make; a government is NOT a business and has entirely different goals and capabilities. I'm talking about the decision-making process itself.

A bill represents a change in policy, sometimes a major change. Such a change should only be undertaken after appropriate analysis, and analysis can only be based on data.

Right now, bills are introduced higglety-pigglety, at the whim of the sponsors. Some bills are pet projects, some are unimportant, and some will affect every person in this country. We trust that things will muddle through, that bills with merit will pass, and those without will get stuck in committee, or at least do no harm. Meantime, the attention of our legislators is drawn equally to all projects. It's a massive case of ADHD institutionalized as standard operating practice.

Government should do what any organization should do before implementing policy changes.

First: Define the problem. Is there a need for a change (bill)? What is the scope of the problem? Define metrics that measure the problem. Collect data to supports the idea that change is needed. Make projections as to how the problem will persist or worsen if no action is taken.

Second: Propose a change. Explain how the proposed change should affect the metrics you are using to measure the problem. How will you know if the change is working?

Third: Identify possible consequences. As far as possible, identify all stakeholders, both for the original problem and for the proposed solution. List possible side effects and analyze their impact.

ANY proposed bill should include these elements. In essence, you are doing a Social Return on Investment (SROI) analysis. The word "social" indicates that neither the investment nor the return is necessarily monetary. But it should still be possible to provide metrics, otherwise you will not know if you are making an effective change.

If bills had to have this sort of analysis to qualify them for introduction, I suspect a lot of bills would never be introduced, or be instantly revealed as political posturing. That might be fine; unimportant bills get passed all the time. Schoolkids might submit a petition to name the bald eagle in the National Zoo George, and there is nothing wrong with congress considering and passing such a bill. There is little need for such a change, but the cost primarily consists of our legislators' time, and the social benefit in terms of PR and political education may make it worthwhile, especially since such a lightweight bill acts as comic relief to the legislators themselves.

But bills such as the voter ID laws may be stopped. (Or perhaps not -- I don't have the data, and that's the point.) A need has not been demonstrated. If there is data (and not just rhetoric) to support such a bill, then it should be provided as supporting documents for the bill's introduction.  However, perhaps the current problem is small, but the consequence of not acting is anticipated to be large. If that is the case, provide projections and a well-supported argument. Balance that against the cost of other consequences -- the disenfranchisement of certain voter blocks.

All of this should be hashed out in committee (including the ability to return the proposal for more data or analysis), and only if the proposal is satisfactory should the bill actually be introduced on the floor.

I think it implementing this one administrative change would redeem the entire governmental decision-making process.

It is essentially a conservative move, in the truest sense of the word. It maintains the status quo unless there is demonstrated need, and ensures (as much as possible) that only effective programs are instituted and financed. And it limits time wasted on political posturing. It is also essentially liberal, in that it identifies need and encourages effective action to address those needs.

Now, if this were a business proposal, it would be implemented first in some sort of test bed, so the entire company is not committed until there is some evidence that the anticipated benefits will materialize. That requires additional metrics -- how will we know this is working? -- and a back-out plan -- if it's not working, how can we cancel its implementation?  The way our legislative system is set up, this isn't really possible. Ideally, each bill would have a standard escape hatch clause-- that is to say, a bill that is passed could be easily revoked in say, a year, if the metrics show that the anticipated benefits are NOT occurring, or that unanticipated consequences ARE occurring. But that's a topic for another day.

Saturday, January 21, 2012

All that *!&%#)&* swearing!

When did "swearing" come to mean the use of scatological and sexual terms? Those terms may be offensive to some; they may be childish or shocking or obscene, but they are not swearing.

Swearing is what you do when you hold up a Bible and say "I promise ... so help me God". It is the use of the Lord's name to emphasize one's sincerity. So why is swearing bad?

One of the 10 Commandments is "Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain".  In other words, don't call on the Lord unless you mean it. Some religious denominations hold that the only proper use of the name of God is prayer and religious discussion; any casual use (like squealing Oh my God! when you see something you like) is a misuse. According to some denominations, so is secular use such as taking an oath.

I was on jury duty last year. Potential jurors were asked to take an oath. Those who objected were permitted to make an "affirmation" instead.  Those who did so were vilified by some ignorant souls who assumed the objectors were atheists. Perhaps some were; it shouldn't matter. Separation of Church and State means that a particular expression of religious belief cannot be required. For whatever reason, these people objected to taking a religious oath. The bailiff had to call for order.

But that is not what we commonly call swearing. Instead, to preserve the purity of our public airwaves, we are not allowed to use certain words. George Carlin's famous seven words were:  shit, piss, fuck, cunt, cocksucker, motherfucker, and tits.  In 1972 he added fart, turd, and twat.

Note that while all of these can be considered rude or even obscene, none are swearing.

Half of these words refer to body waste or functions.  Today, 40 years after Carlin's monologue, most of these bathroom words are no longer taboo. Fart is especially normal. Turd and piss are OK. Shit is borderline;  euphemisms are preferred. Waste, BM, scat, number 2, feces, turd; they're all OK. However, "Oh, shit!" is OK.

The other half refer to sex. Tits, cunt, cocksucker, motherfucker -- these are all considered objectionable; "tits" is probably the most acceptable. "Fuck" is still taboo, at least on the airwaves. It's not the meaning. You can certainly say "rape", which is an even more violent sexual act.  And "WTF" has gone mainstream (I don't know what the censors think the F stands for). In any case, it's obviously not the concept that is taboo, it's the word itself. Somehow, the word will damage our moral fiber. That's ridiculous.

To be sure, I'm not a fan of pottymouth. It's ugly, tiresome,  and shows a singular lack of imagination, if not a lack of vocabulary. There are other adjectives in the English language. Learn them. Express yourself well.

Meanwhile, actual swearing, the type that is forbidden by the 3rd commandment, is commonplace. "Oh my God!" (or OMG!) is a common expression of surprise, even in cartoons meant for kids. Same with "Jesus!" or other overtly religious phrases. If anything, this sort of thing is portrayed as "cute".  Negative expressions seem to be less acceptable. You can usually get by with "hell" or "damn", but for some reason, "Goddamn" is still bleeped out, even when neither "God" nor "damn" is.

But why is the FCC concerned about these words, anyway? If the problem is pottymouth, the government need not step in. What is socially acceptable changes over time, and in any case the taboo, like most social taboos, is socially enforced. If religious swearing is the problem, then the government needs to stay away. Enforcement of religious practice is not a secular problem.

There's another interpretation of the 3rd Commandment, though, that makes more sense. In this interpretation, to "take the name of the Lord thy God" means to operate under the aegis of the Lord, to do things in His name. And "in vain" means to do so falsely. Those who claim to be among God's children,  but who do not act according to his precepts, are breaking this commandment.

That includes those hypocrites who claim to be Christian, but who spew hatred and intolerance.

That's a real problem.

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

Occupy Sodom

Newsflash: The sin of Sodom was not homosexuality. It was greedy inhospitality. 

To paraphrase Ezekiel 16:48-50, the inhabitants of Sodom lived in a land rich with God's gifts. They were prideful, rich, and idle, yet they did not care for the poor. Instead, they were haughty and committed "abominations".  Wait - "abominations". Surely that means homosexuality? 

Uh, no. At least, it was never interpreted that way by the ancient rabbis. In the Babylonian Talmud, a record of thousands of years of rabbinical discussion and analysis, the sin of Sodom is in two parts: first, they were "wicked with their bodies". The rabbis illustrate this using the story of Potiphar's wife enticing Joseph to commit adultery, and by the quoting of laws that seem to encourage adultery. This is sexual misconduct, but the examples are strictly heterosexual. One would think, if homosexuality were the problem, it would be mentioned at least once in the two thousand years of commentary that the Babylonian Talmud represents. 

The second part of Sodom's wickedness is they were "sinners with their money". They lived in a rich land, they themselves had plenty, but they refused to share the blessings God had given them. They not only refused to help the poor and needy, they made helping them a crime. One woman (Lot's daughter, according to the discussion), took pity on a beggar and sneaked bread crusts to him. When the man didn't starve as expected, she was discovered and executed horribly. 

Just as bad, the inhabitants of Sodom were lethally inhospitable towards strangers and travelers. They treated them as did Procrustes in Greek legend; if they were too tall to fit on a cot, the extra height would be cut off; if too short, they would be racked. No differences were to be tolerated. The Talmud especially castigates the four judges in Sodom who incorporated this selfish greed and inhospitality into law.

That seems an awful lot like what the Occupy movement is protesting, doesn't it?

Oh yes -- and the "abominations"? Talmudic scholars held that to be their violation of the rules of hospitality. They came in a mob, threatening the visiting angels (to whom, by contrast, Lot had offered hospitality. Lot's hospitality qualified him and his family to be spared).

Interesting essay on this topic by Rabbi Steven Pik-Nathan.